Packaging Review

Score your YouTube thumbnail + title packaging using John's Thumbnail Pyramid framework.

Free

3 reviews per day

Unlimited

$9/month →

New here? Sign up for 3 free reviews / day

or sign up with email

member?

Unlimited reviews. Cancel anytime. Have a coupon? Enter it at checkout.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy, and to receive marketing emails from The Creator Playbook. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Review Your Packaging

Upload your title and thumbnail. We'll give you feedback on your packaging as if you were talking directly to John.

Heads up: this tool is built for finished, ready-to-publish thumbnails — not works-in-progress. You'll get the sharpest feedback when the package is done.

Choose Your Style

Real World

Your audience prefers thumbnails that look real — genuine environments, authentic moments, and natural lighting.

YouTube Style

Your audience prefers thumbnails that are polished and pop — bold colors, high contrast, engineered backgrounds, and elements that jump off the screen.

📸

Drop your thumbnail here

or click to select (JPEG, PNG, WebP — max 20MB)

Images over 4.5MB will take considerably longer to review. Compress before upload for faster replies.

Video Title *

The title is half the package. We'll evaluate how thumbnail + title work together.

Reference Thumbnail optional

Drop a reference thumbnail

A winning thumbnail (yours or someone else's) to compare against

Upload a top performer you're trying to match or a competitor's thumbnail you admire. We'll compare your package against it.

Target Audience

Looking for specific feedback?

Analyzing your packaging...

Analyzing your thumbnail and title using the Packaging Pyramid...